Two years ago you commenters drafted your favorite flavors of ice cream (Drew started things off with one of my favorites, mint chocolate chip). After 241 comments we were left with an impressive list that I still consult on occasion. Well now the time has come to revisit the ice cream issue, this time with a focus on the toppings. Anything you’ve ever enjoyed on top of a scoop is eligible, so go nuts.

I’ll start things off with a basic staple, hot fudge. Oh you warm, soft, chocolately whore. I could drink you for hours. You’re often overlooked, but you are so very essential.