Class of the ‘04 Tards: Large Benjamin vs. Bitter Elisha. WHO YA GOT?


With the game in London this weekend, Drew suggested that this match-up should be between football and soccer, but that’s not really much of a contest, much like the Saints and the Chargers. Instead, two of the first-round QBs from the 2004 draft who aren’t Marmalard face off for the first time since their rookie seasons. Since then, each has picked up his own piece of hardware (and by that, I don’t mean the metal plate in Ben’s head) and has for the most part shed his once reductive reputation (Ben: He’s a game manager! Eli: He fucking sucks!). Will this game finally settle who was the class of that draft? I’m a Steelers fan and even I don’t give a shit. But maybe you do. So, WHO YA GOT?

Contestants

Ben Roethlisberger________________Eli Manning

What kind of man-child is he?

Intellectual________________Emotional

Predisposed to retardery because

From Ohio___________________From the seed of a Manning

Leakage

Cranial_________________Bed

Credits success to

Plaxico Burress, for whatever reason_______His mom, specifically her cooking and spooning technique

DOES HE LIKE WHEN COACH IS COACHING?

Flaws in his game

Holds ball too long, thinks he can shake off any D-lineman____Overthrows even 6′ 5″ receivers

Would prefer it if

His line blocks Justin Tuck___He can retire now. He got his ring. WHAT MORE DO YOU PEOPLE WANT?!

Best when

Outside the pocket_______________Inside a karaoke bar

Likes squash?

“HARF HARF HARF I LIKE WHEN STUFF GO SQUASH”_________”You bet your motherflippin’ life!”

Finishing move

Fires agent for neglecting choco taco clause in big contract_____Blows off undeservedly hot wife for Double Stuf races with Pey-Pey

Tags: , , ,

25 Responses to “Class of the ‘04 Tards: Large Benjamin vs. Bitter Elisha. WHO YA GOT?”

  1. Leid Says:

    Steelers in six.

  2. dinosaur Says:

    When Big Ben took the Wunderlich test at the pre-draft combine, his score was “bacon.”

  3. Jay Says:

    Roflsberger because picturing him yelling “HI DAVID” and “GLUG GLUG GLUG” makes me laugh more than bitter Eli.

  4. The Stig Says:

    @dinosaur:

    Followed immediately by HARF.

  5. StuScottBooyahs Says:

    Leakage

    Cranial_________________Bed

    HARF HARF HARF THATS GOOD JOKES

  6. Favre's Next Interception Says:

    Don’t mention bacon around Bettis – he’ll tear you apart to get at it.

  7. Slothrop Says:

    Fat guy, awkward interview; Bettis has become Farley. HARF HARF HARF, Beverly Hill Ninja was funny cause he’s a fat ninja.

  8. Slash Says:

    Ben, of course, because you gotta respect the Choco Taco clause.

  9. smurphette Says:

    Ben Rongrastname, because HI DONOVAN still kills me.

  10. Jay Cutler Smug Prick Face Says:

    HI ELI!!!

  11. Haterade Says:

    Ape your a hack

  12. Animal Mother Says:

    Eli, only because Ben still doesn’t know where Bettis is from.

  13. Christmas Ape Says:

    Haterade needs a spelling aide

  14. Haterade Says:

    Seriously? Well maybe I will go down to the stoar and get some Gatoraid, and it will help me thinck of better ways to spell my plaes on wurds.

    Dumbass

  15. SonOfDad Says:

    A better matchup would have been their women vs. each other.

    Missy Peregrym vs. Abbey McGrew-Manning?

    Rawr!

  16. Ben Says:

    The scary thing is that this could easily be the Super Bowl matchup in February.

  17. 310ToJoba Says:

    “HINES DOESN’T LET ME CARRY MONEY!”

  18. jackin'4beats Says:

    OH HI MISSY. CAN’T TALK NOW…WALKING. OK BAI NOW.

  19. Gino Tourettsa Says:

    Don’t let it come to karaoke- Eli’s been working on the Journey catalogue.

  20. Ol' Moonvest Says:

    I’ve never been one for sweepstakes. Monopoly game for a million bucks? No thanks. Golden ticket to see the Willy Wonka factory? I’ll pass. But I tripled my Oreo consumption when I saw that advertisement. I WILL take you down, Mannings.

  21. Jay Says:

    @SonofDad: Wait. Roflsberger landed Missy fucking Peregrym? Does she have some sort of fetish for the mentally retarded? Can I pull off mentally retarded? Where does she live? STAY TUNED

  22. robocats Says:

    If Ben carried money around, he’d just end up buying too many of those wax juice bottles at the candy store and getting indigestion.

  23. robocats Says:

    @haterade

    …that’s not what he was talking about when he said spelling aide, you might want to reread your post before you get your panties all in a bunch. Fuck, way to take it way too personally.

  24. 310ToJoba Says:

    @ Haterade

    “Your” none too bright, but keep at it champ.

  25. Travis Henry's fifth kid Says:

    I HOPE SOMEONE TAPED THE NEW ENTOURAGE FOR ME

Leave a Reply