Face it, your life sucks. You weekdays are boring, you sleep through your weekends, and even your most eventful evenings are scattered among nights of cheap, fatty dinners and sessions of underhanded self-loathing. You are hardly redeemable as a human being. And we would know.
Fortunately for you (and for us), Hollywood never lets facts get in the way of bad cinema. The screenplay documenting your shitty existance, after a few focus meetings and a near-infinite number of re-writes, will be perfect for the silver screen. Remember the time you fucked that hot blonde in the back room at Piggly Wiggly? Neither do we! But there it is, on page 70, written out in all its artistic glory.
Today, good people, you are casting the person that would play you in this movie.
The Rules:
–You are picking this person as they existed IN THEIR PRIME.
Think Steve McQueen circa The Cincinnati Kid or Adam Sandler circa Happy Gilmore. They do not have to be alive today.
–They do not necessarily have to be actors.
Most of you are going to fuck this up anyway, so go ahead and embarrass yourselves creatively.
–No one can be chosen twice, regardless of which era that person is taken.
For example, you could take Drew Barrymore from ET, or Drew Barrymore from Charlie’s Angels. Not both. Again, some of you are stupid and will fuck this up. I apologize to both of our literate readers that naturally would have understood this.
–People back out of shit in Hollywood all the time, so take an understudy. Or six.
Don’t let your movie go to shit because your main guy bailed two weeks before shooting to be the next General Zod. Get a backup, but wait 10 picks before doing so. Same as always.
With the first pick, I’ll keep it contemporary and select the incomparable Don Cheadle. Black people are always cooler than white people. Plus, this guy could read a fucking Human Resources policy book and leave me transfixed. Fortunately, making my life interesting will be only slightly more difficult than that.
Get to it.



A week late with a quarter in hand I take Will Smith.
Thanks and goodnight.
Vincent Chase is a fictional character from Entourage.
I’m late, but I only need one pick: Paul Robeson.
John Krasinski from the Office. Creatively funny dude, and gets to choose between banging Pam or Karen. That’s called a win…win
I would like the record to show that no one selected Cary Grant or James Stewart. What a waste.
Clint Eastwood circa Dirty Harry.
I don’t know how many people saw Russell Crowe’s interview with Steve Kroft on 60 minutes tonight, but Drew’s pick looks better and better by the second.
Quentin Tarantino
I look just like the sorry bastard. He could also be penciled in to direct.
jenna fischer was my first choice but she’s already taken…
so katherine heigl
Michael Keaton in “Night Shift,” one of the two funniest movies of all time, along with “My Cousin Vinny.”
F’ing Terry O’Quinn circa 1st-2nd season of Lost.
I’ll take Special Ed, cause…
I got it made…
People used to tell me I looked like him in High School.
I cannot believe he hasn’t been taken yet: Ricardo Montalbon, circa Wrath of Khan
Did nobody pick Seth Rogen? I get a lot of people saying I’m like Seth Rogen. My name is Ben, I’m a stoner, and I have unprotected sex, so you can see where the “Knocked Up” comparisons come from.
‘N yeah, the Chief wanted him earlier, but behind Brando, Eastwood and Stuntcock…’n only two picks ahead of Jon Stewart. Y’all know Denzel gon’ be taken by then, so that jus’ don’ count.
Late to the party, but with the steal of the draft: Denzel Washington, you feel me?
brendan fraser
I know he is a d bag but i look just like him. i hear it at least twice a week.
In a beautifully choreographed martial arts epic, the part of ME will be played by bad guy extraordinaire BOLO YEUNG.
Charlie Sheen (1986)
Joe Pesci (1990)
Taye Diggs (present)
Ah-nold (circa Predator)
BOLO YEUNG (circa bloodsport)
Chong Li! Chong Li! Chong Li!
I’ll end with a hot older actress-Helen Mirren. The lady has great tits for her age, plus I’d have a British accent. Bonus.
1. Rachel McAdams
2. Jenna Fischer
3. Helen Mirren
If I were a man I would have chosen Peter Krause by now.
John Turturro from Big Lebowski.
“Don’t nobody fuck wit da Jesus”
Michael Douglas, from his Wall Street Fatal Attraction days.
I am way late to the party, but I’ll grab John C. Reilly in the Reed Rothschild days. Oh heckfire, I’ll break the rules and pick a few since I am 7 hours behind.
College Years: Reed Rothschild
That time I tried drugs: Crispin Glover
For all those uncomfortable silence moments and someone needs to say something funny enough to break the ice: Matthew Perry
For my gangsta flava: Jake Busy (aka Shasta McNasty)
Dolemite- I’d like to point out that Jack Nicholson is BY FAR the best pick in this draft. I’m pretty certain that this is undisputable.
With that said, I select Rusel Crowe. He kicks ass, literally.
I joined the party late, but I’ll take Avery Brooks (HAWK) because he’s almost as bad-ass as me.
I may have missed Jessica Alba… so, just to not break the rules, I will go out of the box and choose Alessandra Ambrosio, VS model.
And in the script, I would include some self love, just so I could say I’ve been touched by Alessandra Ambrosio, VS model.
Buster Poindexter
Tim Matheson, from the Animal house days. Cool motherfucker.
For the older me, Bradley Whitford.
And for that period in my life where I was a slutty lesbian who spent 4 years in a swedish prison, Angelina Jolie.
John John…Will Arnett is an AWESOME pick.
I’m going with Jenna Fischer, Pam from the office.
Justin Long
Sweet baby jebus. I forgot two understudies.
2. Freedom Williams – Anyone who is that confident in his ability to make people do anything especially sweat must be wise beyond his years.
3. Walton Goggins (Shane Vendrell) – The greatest undercover name in the history of the universe. Cletus. Van. Damme.
I’m gonna go with Ron Livingston.
Will Arnett
Number 4 is a true value pick this low in the draft. He’d play me in my mid-20s when I became a sargeant in an elite army unit assigned to protect the earth from aliens and communists (and alien communist rebels).
ME:
starring: Arnold Schwarzenegger (circa – predator or commando)
How did I land this pick so low???
Anne Hathaway circa Brokeback Mountain
Heath Ledger circa Brokeback Mountain. He was the one taking it, right? I mean that’s what I heard. … Wow did I just think or say that? Um … Oh boy. I didn’t mean to let that one out. Let’s try again.
Primary: Al Sharpton circa Tawana Brawley. You can’t front on the sweat suits and fat gold chains.
Understudy: Cuba Gooding Jr. circa BITH. Ain’t nuthin’ like the demin shirt tucked in the tight demin jeans. His evolution to retard in Radio parallels my growth or lack thereof.
Sean Penn. Because he’s an asshole. Just like me.
John Kruk, ca. 1991
There are only so many sloppy lefties with power laying around, and none of them are in Hollywood.
Ok brother. I did a lil ctrl-f and didn’t see it, but whatever.
marcello mastroianni is my next pick, then i’m gonna take ricky gervais….aaand i’m done.
Hugh Reilly
All of these picks (in drafted order) would do well in the lead of my life story, “Growing up, Throwing up: The Story of anOversexed Shank of Manliness Hellbent on Drinking and Yelling at Everything.”:
Lead: Brando
Clint Eastwood (good for flashbacks of my gunslinging toddler years)
John Holmes (stuntcock!)
Denzel Washington
James. Fucking. Dean.
Jon Stewart
Tom Hanks
Sean Penn
Will Ferrell
Randy Quaid (for the lost years)
George C. Scott
David Hasselhoff
Dustin Hoffman
Bill Brasky
I would also pick Haley Joel Osmont, but not for my movie. I’d just kick him in the neck.
Rex Grossman, without a doubt.
Only he can turn my life story into the sexcapade I always dreamed it would be when I was a little boy.
Jessica Rabbit, no question.
To sum up:
Primary: Jake Gyllenhaal
Understudy: River Phoenix
The bad ass years: Jack Bauer
The retarded years: Helen Keller
The humorous years: David Cross
The psychotic years: Willem Dafoe
@sledgod, damn you and your knowledge, I was busy searching IMDB to get his name.
“Stanley yelled at me today. That was one of the most frightening experiences of my life.”
For his acting chops and his weight, John Goodman.
WF
(“What self-esteem issues?”)
@robert: i took orson welles with my third pick a while ago.
If I can pick a sista, I pick N’Bushe Wright, specifically from “Blade.” She’s good-looking and smart and can handle a shotgun.
Rachel McAdams. Damned fine actress, and my biggest non-sexual crush.
Whoever chose Danny Trejo and Bruce Campbell rock my ass. Great picks.
Tim Couch
Sam Riley, circa now. I can only hope to brood as much as he does in Control.
Kurt Russell circa Tango & Cash to wardrobe.
Here’s my list:
Robert DeNiro
Gene Hackman
Clark Gable
Kurt Russell
Good ’nuff.
My fellow green-eyed devil, Terrence Howard. Ask a woman why.
not as the weak punk from ‘Crash’, though.
@awful chief: with Peter Weller you also get ‘Robocop’, right? Excellent selection.
Since everyone is picking a token brotha here…I’ll also join that bandwagon.
Taye Diggs plays me in the urban adaptation of my life story.
“He was a poor misguided street youth with a good heart and a passion for tennis…the one thing that could get him out of the hood.”
I would then become a tennis pro, have arms bigger than Raphael Nadal and bang my way through all the hot Russian girls on the pro tour.
This shit just writes itself.
ME:
starring – Charlie Sheen (circa ’86)
understudy- Joe Pesci (circa ’90)
urban version – Taye Diggs (present day)
there would have to be many crackers.
I guess you could shoot in Kansas or Iowa.
Peter North. Too modest?
I am a white, 20-year-old male journalism major. Thusly, I select Leslie David Baker, who plays Stanley on The Office.
my alternate choice would be BOTH fittys (fitties?), larry and cent.
there would have to be many crackers.
Going old school again: I can’t believe Sidney Poitier is still around this late. YOINK.
What a steal i’m about to pull off here…Kurt Russell, from any John Carpenter movie.
Steve Zahn, from Saving Silverman and Employee of the Month (not the one w/ Jessica Simpson).
By the way, today’s picture of Will Leitch is even more emo than yesterday’s. He almost looks like a woman there.
joe don baker.
peace.
Here’s my ridiculously long list:
Richard Roundtree
Sean Connery
Paul Newman
Ray Liotta
Charlton Heston
Laurence Fishburne
Robert Redford
Sam Rockwell
Jim Brown
For the record, I’ve got the men who brought us John Shaft, James Bond, Cool Hand Luke, Henry Hill, George Taylor, Furious Styles, the Sundance Kid, Chuck Barris, and Slaughter/Jefferson.
I think together they might be able to capture the magic that is me.
If not, I’ll go with Fred “the Hammer” Williamson.
Bill Allen…Cru Jones from Rad
Who wants to go ass-sliding???
Willem Dafoe. I know his face is all jacked up; but if I ever decide to kill someone someday, I can’t imagine anyone better.
BTW: we’ve now taken a decent portion of the Platoon cast:
Charlie Sheen
Johnny Depp
Forest Whitaker
Johnny Drama
Willem Dafoe
Stanley Tucci. Dude’s just hilarious.
Ray Allen from He Got Game, Young Rosario Dawson playing a hood rat, that’s my type of woman.
And that cinches my token black person.
1. Christian Bale
2. Tommy Chong
3. Gael Garcia Burnal
4. Bruce Campbell
5. Eric Bana
6. Ray Allen
Milla Jovavich, don’t really care from when, though I don’t think I’d look good in orange hair. She’s taller than me, but I have slightly bigger boobs, so it comes out (sorta) even, looks-wise.
I just noticed the NC-17 rating at the top of the page. When did that get there?
Peter Weller. From? the adventures of buckaroo bonzai across the 8th dimension. The way he excelled at lines like “Hey, hey, hey. Don’t be mean. We don’t have to be mean because, remember, no matter where you go, there you are.”, he should be able to adapt well to being a second rate KSK commenter.
My understudy will be Joe Pesci circa Goodfellas. Nobody in my movie would talk any shit to me without being thoroughly pistol whipped. And I get to creatively and excessively use the word “fuck” throughout.
ME
starring – Charlie Sheen in 1986
understudy #1 – Joe Pesci in 1990
Cary Grant, motherfuckers.
Dammit.
Jim Brown. From “100 Rifles,” where he gets to bullshit with Burt Reynolds and fuck the hell out of a scorchingly hot Raquel Welch.
christopher walken = gone
Christopher Walken. From “Annie Hall.”